Justice That Bleeds: Should revenge be a part of the justice system?

…Unsplash

 

            Retribution is one of the three main justifications of punishment. It is a concept which is not only well-developed in the literature about punishment but also discussed by the judiciary.[i] In Ryan v The Queen, retribution was described as necessary to maintain public confidence in courts. It was stated that ‘public confidence in the courts to do justice would likely to be lost’ if courts ignored the retributive aspect of punishment.[ii] One of the most intriguing questions is how far is too far? The Death Penalty Information Center, states that approximately 3% of the U.S. executions between 1890 and 2010 were botched in some way.[iii] Nevertheless, it is difficult to discuss this as inflicting harm and suffering upon those who once did so themselves in the minds of many is often either inconsequential or just.

 

            It is one of the challenges while responding to serious criminal wrongdoings to meet the community’s need for retribution. R v Gordon stated that not only does the community need to be satisfied that the offender is given what they deserved, but also the victim.[iv] It is unrealistic to think that harsh sentences or capital punishment are just for the objective greater good and do not reflect society’s desire for revenge. After all, punishment is supposed to express the moral outrage of the community.[v] But, does it actually contribute to its betterment? It is well-known that many states in the U.S. still have the death penalty. One of the most common justifications for its use is the belief that such punishment has a unique deterrent effect.[vi] And yet, there has been a notable lack of empirical research evidence to support this.[vii] Theoretically, some people may indeed be deterred, but the successful defence of such a drastic sentence would require not the mere assertion of deterrence but lower rates of capital offences.[viii] So far, there is no credible link between the death penalty and reduction in serious crime.[ix] This is further collaborated by similar results in studies from beyond the U.S.[x]

 

            Moreover, treating revenge as an element of the justice system poses a real risk for the society as a whole. Although wanting retribution is a normal reaction, it is also important to acknowledge that a society obsessed with vengeance is ultimately harmed by it. It is impossible to ignore how certain groups are disproportionately impacted by inequalities in the justice system. For instance, people living in poverty are more often sentenced to death compared to those in better financial situations as they cannot afford a lawyer, and the free legal assistance they may receive is of low quality.[xi] Hence, a country that is willing to sentence its citizens to death is also a country that, in some capacity, ends up targeting the poor. It is also a matter of concern how domestic and sexual abuse may be ignored as a mitigating factor.[xii] In the context of capital punishment, imposing such sentences in cases where there has been self-defence constitutes a major violation of international law.[xiii] Even without the death penalty on the line, these factors still play a role as financial status and social perception impacts investigations and court proceedings all the time. For instance, according to data from 2023/2024, Indigenous children make up to 5.7% of the Australian population aged 10-17, but the rate of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander youth in detention on average day was around twenty six times the rate of non-Indigenous young people.[xiv] Overall, the less the justice system cares about intersectionality, root causes and rehabilitation, the more it will deepen the existing social inequalities.

 

There probably never will be a clear consensus and closure as to what to do with those who commit the most heinous of crimes. In truth, both victims and perpetrators deserve justice. For some of those who committed crimes, justice may mean life without parole. However, in a human and effective justice system there should be no place for empty cruelty. This approach creates systemic dysfunction. Not only because it does not serve any bigger purpose and only creates more social divide, but it also creates a different kind of systemic dysfunction. A society which prioritises retribution normalises violence as a way of solving conflicts. It desensitises to harm and pain of others if they are an acceptable target. Whether perpetrators deserve societal wrath and revenge is a question that many will probably never feel to be fully resolved. One thing should be certain, good people do not deserve what a bleak spectacle of revenge does to them.


 ─────────────────────────────────────────

References

[i] Mirko Bagaric, ‘The negation of venting in Australian sentencing: Denouncing denunciation and retribution’ (2014) 88 Australian Law Journal 502, 507.

[ii] Ryan v The Queen (2001) 206 CLR 267, [46].

[iii] Death Penalty Information Center, ‘Botched Executions’ (Web Page) < https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/executions/botched-executions>.

[iv] R v Gordon (1994) 71 A Crim R 459, 468.

[v] R v Valentini (1980) 48 FLR 416, 420.

[vi] The Death Penalty Project, Deterrence and the Death Penalty (Policy Position Paper, 2022) https://deathpenaltyproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/The-Death-Penalty-Project_Policy-Deterrence.pdf

[vii] Ibid, 2.

[viii] Ibid.

[ix] Ibid.

[x] Ibid, 3.

[xi] United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, ‘Death Penalty Disproportionately Affects the Poor, UN Rights Experts Warn’ (Press Release, 6 October 2017) < https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2017/10/death-penalty-disproportionately-affects-poor-un-rights-experts-warn>.

[xii] Ibid.

[xiii] Ibid.

[xiv] Australian Human Rights Commission, ‘First Peoples communities and criminal justice’ (Article, 22 April 2026)

Next
Next

Seven Years On: Are Australia’s Corporate Whistleblower Laws Working?